I made a comment recently somewhere that stated no one could confirm for me what it meant to be white and got a lot of down votes. Not fussed, but only one person actually gave a direct answer and it was not a detailed or elaborate answer though.
I have asked this question multiple times from different people on this site but have never received the same answer. Often I am accused of being a jew or a nigger or something, you know the usual response, but that's just deflecting. I want to collate all the serious answers I get to help understand the differences in peoples opinions.
If you say it's a europium person, which European border and why? How far back in time do you consider it the right border? How much of a mix can you be before you are not considered European? How do you explain the the sudden off switch that occurs to people who are on the direct opposite side of this border. How do you consider the immigration and variation over thousands of years. How far back in your ancestry do you stop looking?
If European is not your specific point of reference, then what is it? Skin colour? How do you define the skin colour? many asians have light skin, how do you specifically remove them? If it is genetics, which genetics and how do you account for everything above? Do you apply your position on people based solely on looks and why? Why do you not wait fora genetic report from a lab to confirm their genetics? Which specific genes are you looking for? If you believe these genes need to be isolated to create a pure white race, how do you treat the lack of genetic diversity that always leads to degradation?
Do you consider the previous positions such as Italians not being white. Some people do not consider slavs white, is this a cultural, genetic or European border thing. How do you account for the changes in culture of thousands of years, conquered cultures, border/land expansions that come with the culture change and other things that change genetics and borders and the ways people live over thousands of years.
I will ignore anyone that doesn't give me an actual answer.
When you say slavic, anglo, nordic, euro, what does this actually mean? Do you refer to specific countries? What time periods do you consider? Do you count the times when the borders of these countries differ? You say genetics, but what specific genetics? What genetics does a person need to fit within these groups? If we go back 2000 years do these groups still exist as they do today and if not, why do we not consider it the same as today? What about countries that exist at the edge of these groups? At what point is a person suddenly not considered one of these labels?
AnmanIndustries -3 points 2.1 years ago
When you say slavic, anglo, nordic, euro, what does this actually mean? Do you refer to specific countries? What time periods do you consider? Do you count the times when the borders of these countries differ? You say genetics, but what specific genetics? What genetics does a person need to fit within these groups? If we go back 2000 years do these groups still exist as they do today and if not, why do we not consider it the same as today? What about countries that exist at the edge of these groups? At what point is a person suddenly not considered one of these labels?