B should retain ownership, since property rights are fundamental to a functioning society.
B should then sell the flute to A, since their skill set and potential career as a musician creates a demand for a mutually beneficial trade. B gets money for the product they’ve created and A gets to buy ownership rights to a tool that’ll allow them to make money. Everybody wins.
Well, everybody wins but C. C should get a damn job. What a whiny, lazy cunt.
Child B, unless she transferred ownership of it to one of the other children, in which case it belongs to them, and she can only hope to get them to transfer ownership back to her.
I remember when we discussed this on old Voat. The best answer: Kill the person who asked the question and pretend it was never asked.
The explanation: Once the question gets asked, people will realize that it implicitly creates the Office of Flute Distribution. Then they will compete for the post of Lord High Flute Distributor. Soon the competition will turn violent. And escalate. By the time the civil war is over, child B has been killed by falling masonry and the flute crushed beneath the treads of a tank. (a BT-5, supplied by Bolsheviks.)
Doesn't change anything. Maybe B is super rich because he isn't a lazy bum? Robin Hood returned taxes to the people. He didn't steal from the rich, he stole from the state the money that the state stole from the people.
[ - ] Mershekel 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 21, 2021 00:18:58 ago (+1/-0)*
C is simply socialism, the standard 'normie' or 'leftist' answer, i.e. 'from each according to his ability to each according to his needs' (Communist Manifesto), which as someone on old Voat keenly observed was a quasi-moral justification of a parasitic relationship.
In the contemporary West it plays out like this:
Whites/B are superior to nonwhites/C; It is bad that Whites/B are superior to nonwhites/C; Strength must be transferred from Whites/B to nonwhites/C; In order to attempt equalizing nonwhites/C to Whites/B; If they become equal than the 'badness' of inequality has been solved and that is 'good'.
Obviously I find this reasoning wrong.
A (redistribution to the best) or B (no redistribution) are obviously vastly superior to C (redistribution to the worst), though it's not so easy to dismiss A. A isn't groid reasoning because C is groid reasoning. When are they ever the best at anything outside of sheer fantasy? That being said, only B (capitalism/private property) and C (socialism/welfarism/redistributionism) are serious options in the West (there is no society that has a sort of 'reverse' socialism in which we make/give things to those best qualified to use them, only standard socialism in which we give things to those we consider 'most needy' and generally worst qualified, i.e. the perpetual nonwhite underclasses). It also goes without saying that the West is moving further from B and towards C (anyone who seriously entertains A would probably be considered a far-right extremist these days).
None of them should get it. Melt it down and use the materials to build something people need. Music is nothing but a waste of time and used for propaganda. A flute is a gateway instrument into degenerate cultures. You give the flute to a girl and then she goes to band camp... turns into a whore starts listening to shit skin music and twerking for niggers and pedo faggots. Next thing you know she's in collage soaking up the marxist propaganda and marching in the street for "equal rights". Then she's on the internet naked and using the flute in ways it shouldn't be used.
Woman shouldn't play music, vote or have any say other than bearing children and working at the homestead.
[ + ] RabbiKinderschtupper
[ - ] RabbiKinderschtupper 20 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 11:04:05 ago (+20/-0)
[ + ] try
[ - ] try 5 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 16:50:10 ago (+5/-0)
THE PROPER artwork makes Child B decision more clear!
https://files.catbox.moe/ybzp1c.jpg
*HILARIOUS proper version in THAT link!*
=========
see?
https://files.catbox.moe/ybzp1c.jpg
heh!
[ + ] Nathrandir
[ - ] Nathrandir 15 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 11:00:05 ago (+15/-0)
B should then sell the flute to A, since their skill set and potential career as a musician creates a demand for a mutually beneficial trade. B gets money for the product they’ve created and A gets to buy ownership rights to a tool that’ll allow them to make money. Everybody wins.
Well, everybody wins but C. C should get a damn job. What a whiny, lazy cunt.
[ + ] toobaditworks
[ - ] toobaditworks 8 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 11:00:53 ago (+9/-1)
[ + ] account deleted by user
[ - ] account deleted by user 8 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 11:47:06 ago (+8/-0)
[ + ] getting_old_fast
[ - ] getting_old_fast 4 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 14:52:30 ago (+4/-0)
[ + ] try
[ - ] try 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 17:01:35 ago (+1/-0)
I FIXED ART and removed gender issues!
https://files.catbox.moe/ybzp1c.jpg
Now its clearer and less kike marxist jew educator propaganda!
[ + ] Wahaha
[ - ] Wahaha 0 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 16:41:57 ago (+0/-0)
[ + ] Paradoxical003
[ - ] Paradoxical003 3 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 12:22:08 ago (+3/-0)
[ + ] Xigbar68
[ - ] Xigbar68 3 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 12:20:12 ago (+3/-0)
Also, I think there was an edit of this where Child A & C were niggers. Didn't save it though.
[ + ] try
[ - ] try 2 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 17:03:46 ago (+2/-0)
I FIXED ART and removed gender issues, but made races fit their categories!
https://files.catbox.moe/ybzp1c.jpg
[ + ] happytoes
[ - ] happytoes 2 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 17:36:42 ago (+2/-0)
The explanation: Once the question gets asked, people will realize that it implicitly creates the Office of Flute Distribution. Then they will compete for the post of Lord High Flute Distributor. Soon the competition will turn violent. And escalate. By the time the civil war is over, child B has been killed by falling masonry and the flute crushed beneath the treads of a tank. (a BT-5, supplied by Bolsheviks.)
[ + ] Wahaha
[ - ] Wahaha 2 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 13:18:38 ago (+2/-0)
[ + ] yesiknow
[ - ] yesiknow 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 13:26:39 ago (+1/-0)
[ + ] oldblo
[ - ] oldblo 0 points 2.8 yearsJun 21, 2021 03:03:09 ago (+0/-0)
Was Robin Hood a bad person or a local hero?
[ + ] Wahaha
[ - ] Wahaha 0 points 2.8 yearsJun 21, 2021 04:11:53 ago (+0/-0)
Robin Hood returned taxes to the people. He didn't steal from the rich, he stole from the state the money that the state stole from the people.
[ + ] Mershekel
[ - ] Mershekel 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 21, 2021 00:18:58 ago (+1/-0)*
In the contemporary West it plays out like this:
Whites/B are superior to nonwhites/C;
It is bad that Whites/B are superior to nonwhites/C;
Strength must be transferred from Whites/B to nonwhites/C;
In order to attempt equalizing nonwhites/C to Whites/B;
If they become equal than the 'badness' of inequality has been solved and that is 'good'.
Obviously I find this reasoning wrong.
A (redistribution to the best) or B (no redistribution) are obviously vastly superior to C (redistribution to the worst), though it's not so easy to dismiss A. A isn't groid reasoning because C is groid reasoning. When are they ever the best at anything outside of sheer fantasy? That being said, only B (capitalism/private property) and C (socialism/welfarism/redistributionism) are serious options in the West (there is no society that has a sort of 'reverse' socialism in which we make/give things to those best qualified to use them, only standard socialism in which we give things to those we consider 'most needy' and generally worst qualified, i.e. the perpetual nonwhite underclasses). It also goes without saying that the West is moving further from B and towards C (anyone who seriously entertains A would probably be considered a far-right extremist these days).
[ + ] quidgybo
[ - ] quidgybo 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 23:55:20 ago (+1/-0)
[ + ] oldblo
[ - ] oldblo 0 points 2.8 yearsJun 21, 2021 03:03:50 ago (+0/-0)
[ + ] account deleted by user
[ - ] account deleted by user 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 17:24:10 ago (+1/-0)*
[ + ] mannerbund
[ - ] mannerbund 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 14:29:21 ago (+1/-0)
[ + ] NaturalSelectionistWorker
[ - ] NaturalSelectionistWorker 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 12:43:11 ago (+1/-0)
[ + ] Steelerfish
[ - ] Steelerfish 0 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 21:59:43 ago (+0/-0)
[ + ] CMajor
[ - ] CMajor 0 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 15:49:50 ago (+1/-1)
[ + ] account deleted by user
[ - ] account deleted by user 3 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 16:55:24 ago (+3/-0)
[ + ] oldblo
[ - ] oldblo -1 points 2.8 yearsJun 21, 2021 02:57:37 ago (+0/-1)
Ideally with brass knuckles. A lesson will be learned and the problem is unlikely to arise again.
[ + ] toobaditworks
[ - ] toobaditworks -4 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 10:56:14 ago (+4/-8)*
Woman shouldn't play music, vote or have any say other than bearing children and working at the homestead.
[ + ] NiggerFaggot
[ - ] NiggerFaggot 13 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 11:24:24 ago (+13/-0)
Oh…
[ + ] account deleted by user
[ - ] account deleted by user 4 points 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 17:00:56 ago (+4/-0)
[ + ] Hadza
[ - ] Hadza 1 point 2.8 yearsJun 20, 2021 11:36:35 ago (+4/-3)
[ + ] oldblo
[ - ] oldblo 0 points 2.8 yearsJun 21, 2021 03:10:14 ago (+0/-0)
As if they were fit to control others and dictate the value of something on behalf of others.